Deal or Dilution
Learners negotiate a fictional £2 million Series A with VC Fund XYZ: valuation and liquidation preference, option pool, anti-dilution, board and founder vesting. The cap table updates as they go, then a waterfall shows who gets what in a £3m, £8m and £40m sale.
- 5 clauses
- 2 checks
- 15–20 minutes
- Cap table and waterfall
What learners practise
After playing, learners can:
- calculate an investor’s stake from the pre-money valuation and the investment;
- explain 1× non-participating, 1× participating and 2× participating liquidation preferences, and show their effect in a waterfall;
- explain how an option pool created before the money dilutes founders;
- compare full ratchet and weighted-average anti-dilution in a down round;
- discuss board composition and founder vesting as control terms.
It suits business, management, enterprise and design courses, and founder workshops. No prior finance knowledge is needed.
How to run it
In class on one screen
- Before: open the game on the big screen. Split the room into founders and VC partners.
- Each clause (about 2 minutes): one minute for each side to argue, then a vote, then reveal.
- After the option pool and anti-dilution steps: pause on the cap table and the down-round table.
- Results (5 minutes): walk through the waterfall: first the £3m column, then £40m.
How the model works
- Before the round: Founder A 5,000 shares, Founder B 4,000, Angel Network ABC 1,000.
- Investor stake = £2m ÷ (pre-money + £2m). The option pool is a percentage of the fully diluted total after the round, created before the money goes in.
- Waterfall: 1× non-participating = the larger of £2m or the fund’s percentage of the sale price; participating = the preference first, then the fund’s percentage of what is left. All options are treated as granted and exercised; tax and fees are ignored.
- Down round: £1m raised at half the Series A price. Full ratchet re-prices the fund’s shares at the new price; broad-based weighted average uses the standard formula, new price = old price × (A + B) ÷ (A + C).
Answer key
Options are shown in a fixed order for decisions, and shuffled in the class-team games. Stars: 3 = best, 0 = a mistake.
| Case or step | Best answer (3 stars) | The rule behind it |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-money or post-money? | 25% | Pre-money + investment = post-moneyThe investor’s share is the investment divided by the post-money valuation. Always check which one a number refers to. |
| Three term sheets on the table | VC Fund XYZ: £6m pre-money, 1× non-participating preference | Valuation isn’t everythingA higher valuation with harsher terms can leave founders worse off than a lower valuation with clean terms. Non-participating means the investor chooses: its money back, or its share. Participating means both. |
| The option pool | Agree a 10% pool, sized to a real hiring plan for the next 18 months | The pool shuffleA pool created pre-money lowers the real price per share for founders: the headline valuation includes options nobody holds yet. Negotiate its size, based on a hiring plan. |
| Anti-dilution protection | Broad-based weighted average | Down roundsAnti-dilution moves dilution from investors to founders when a later round is cheaper. Weighted average shares the pain; full ratchet puts almost all of it on the founders. |
| Who sits on the board? | Four seats: both founders, one VC director, plus an independent chair everyone agrees on | Control isn’t only sharesBoard seats and investor consent rights (vetoes over big decisions) can matter more than percentages. Read the governance terms as closely as the money. |
| Founder vesting | Four-year vesting with a one-year cliff, with clear good-leaver and bad-leaver terms | LeaversVesting and leaver terms decide what happens to a founder’s shares if they leave. Check how “good leaver” and “bad leaver” are defined. |
| One last check | £2,000,000 (its money back) | WaterfallIn a small sale, the preference protects the investor. In a big sale, it converts to ordinary shares and takes its percentage. |
Debrief questions
Choose two or three
- Which clause cost the founders most in a £3m sale? And in a £40m sale?
- Why might a founder accept a lower valuation for cleaner terms?
- Who is the option pool really paid for by?
- What would you ask for in return if a VC insisted on a full ratchet?
Extension task (30 minutes)
Build the cap table and the waterfall in a spreadsheet. Add a second round (Series B, £6m at £24m pre-money) and show each founder’s share and payout at a £60m sale.
Design choices and limits
- Every company, founder, investor, fund and figure is fictional (Company ABC, Founder A, VC Fund XYZ, Angel Network ABC). Any resemblance to real businesses is coincidental.
- Rules, fees and limits are UK rules, checked on 19 November 2026. They change: check the linked sources before relying on them for a real decision. Scotland-specific points are flagged where they differ.
- Scores are teaching judgements, not legal, tax or financial advice. Real decisions depend on the full facts; founders in Scotland can get free advice from Business Gateway, and elsewhere in the UK from their local growth hub or enterprise agency.
Accessibility of the game
- Works with a keyboard and screen reader; tested with axe-core against WCAG 2.2 AA at desktop and phone widths, with no sideways scrolling at 320 pixels.
- No time limits. Charts and tables carry the same numbers, so nothing depends on seeing the chart.
- Motion respects “reduce motion” settings; sound is off by default.
Sources
- British Business Bank (no date) What is a term sheet?. Available at: https://www.british-business-bank.co.uk/business-guidance/guidance-articles/business-essentials/what-is-a-term-sheet (opens in a new tab) (Accessed: 19 November 2026).
- British Business Bank (no date) Which type of equity finance is right for my business?. Available at: https://www.british-business-bank.co.uk/business-guidance/guidance-articles/finance/which-type-of-equity-finance-is-right-for-my-business (opens in a new tab) (Accessed: 19 November 2026).
- UK Private Capital (no date) Model documents for early stage investments. Available at: https://www.ukprivatecapital.co.uk/policy/industry-guidance-standardised-documents/model-documents-for-early-stage-investments.html (opens in a new tab) (Accessed: 19 November 2026).
Every rule, fee and limit in the game is taken from these official sources, each checked on 19 November 2026. Rules change: check the links before relying on them for a real decision.