Search Showdown
A live team competition for the last session of a search marketing (SEO) module, a training day or an industry guest slot. Teams bring ideas, a transparent simulation shows how each idea is likely to play out in today’s search, including AI answers, and a judge gives the verdict. The judge can be a guest from industry, the lecturer, or the class. It runs from one screen, needs no student devices, and ends with a results reveal and printable certificates.
- 2–8 teams
- Sprint ≈ 30 min · Full ≈ 45 min
- Guest judge online, in the room, or none
- No logins, no student devices
- Certificates for the winners
What learners practise
1. Strategy over tricks
Ten play cards cover the main routes to search visibility, from expert content and original data to local search, video, digital PR and technical fixes. Two are traps that break Google’s spam policies. Learners match a play to a client’s goal instead of reciting tactics.
2. Search with AI answers in it
Every idea is scored for classic results and AI answers. Google says its AI features rest on the same SEO basics, with no special files or markup (Google, 2025), so the game rewards useful, trustworthy, original content over hacks.
3. Pitching to industry
Teams have under a minute to sell one idea with one specific twist, then hear an expert’s honest reaction. That’s the closest a classroom gets to a client meeting.
4. Myth-busting, with stakes
Round 1 tackles beliefs clients still bring to agencies, such as ads boosting rankings or AI-written pages being banned. Teams commit to an answer and a bet before the reveal, so being sure and wrong costs points. Each reveal gives Google’s own evidence and a clue for the pitch round, so the warm-up feeds straight into the main event.
Learning outcomes
After the showdown, learners can:
- select and justify a search strategy for a specific client, audience and goal;
- explain how visibility in AI answers relates to established SEO practice;
- recognise tactics that breach search engine spam policies, and say why they backfire;
- pitch a marketing idea concisely and respond to expert challenge.
It suits search, digital and content marketing modules, marketing degree capstones, apprenticeships, short courses and agency or in-house team training. Learners need only the basics of SEO, which makes it a good end-of-module celebration as well as a revision game.
How to run it
Before the session (10 minutes)
- Open the game and press Set up a showdown: choose Sprint or Full, the number of teams, who judges, and the client.
- If a guest is judging, press Copy set-up link and send it with this guide, so they see exactly what the class will see.
- Test the projector and, if your guest is joining online, share the screen in the call with computer sound on so they hear the timers.
- Have the guide’s answer key to hand.
In the room
- Lights up: teams form (3–6 people), the judge says hello in one sentence.
- Myth or Fact: the client has heard a claim about search. Each team shows thumbs up (fact) or down (myth) and 1–3 fingers for how sure it is. You tap in every team’s call and bet, then press “Lock in and reveal”. Right calls win their bet, wrong calls lose it, and each answer drops a clue for the pitch round.
- The Pitch: show the brief and the 10 cards; start the thinking clock and walk round asking each team for its twist.
- Each team pitches; enter its card, press Run the simulation, then the judge scores out of 10 and can overrule the machine by one point.
- Judge’s wildcard (Full, or Sprint with a guest judge): a number question from their own work, closest guess wins.
- Full only: a plot twist.
- Results reveal, photos, then certificates (now or after class).
Who judges?
- Guest judge (recommended): a practitioner online or in the room. They react, score and add one real insight per round. See the judge’s card.
- You judge: the on-screen prompts give you a question to ask for every card, and the scoring guide keeps it fair.
- The class votes: no judge at all. After the pitches, everyone has one vote and can’t vote for their own team.
Online or hybrid
Share your screen in Teams, Zoom or similar. Teams can sit in breakout rooms during the thinking time and come back to pitch. In-room teams can show their Myth or Fact answers with thumbs; online teams use reactions or the chat. Keep cameras optional.
Scoring
- Myth or Fact: each team bets 1–3 points per statement; right wins the bet, wrong loses it
- The Pitch: simulation 0–5 (the judge can move it ±1) + judge 0–10 (or class votes, scaled to 10)
- Wildcard: 2 points to the closest team (Full, or Sprint with a guest)
- Full only: plot twist 3, 2 or 1
- Ties are broken by the judge’s score, then the simulation.
The game remembers its progress in your browser, so a refresh or a crashed projector won’t lose the scores. After class, open the game again to finish the certificates. Nothing is sent anywhere.
Honest timings
Live games take longer in a real room than on paper. These estimates already allow for teams settling, questions and laughter. The set-up screen recalculates them for your number of teams and pitch length, and a small clock in the header shows how you are doing.
| Part | Sprint | Full |
|---|---|---|
| Welcome, teams, rules | 3 | 3 |
| Round 1: Myth or Fact | 5 (3 statements) | 8 (5 statements) |
| Round 2: brief and thinking time | 6 | 6 |
| Round 2: 5 pitches, simulations and verdicts | 13 | 13 |
| Judge’s wildcard | 4 (with a guest judge; optional) | 4 |
| Round 3: Plot Twist | – | 6 |
| Results reveal and winners’ photos | 4 | 4 |
| Total | ≈ 31 min (≈ 35 with the wildcard) | ≈ 44 min |
In a 60-minute final session, run the Sprint. That leaves time to recap the module, celebrate and take class photos. If you’re running long, shorten the thinking time with “Everyone’s ready”, or use 30-second pitches.
The judge’s card
For guest judges. Thank you for joining! You don’t need to prepare slides. The class will pitch ideas, and your reactions are the most valuable part of the session.
What you’ll be asked to do
- Say hello in one sentence: who you are and what you do.
- Myth or Fact (20 seconds each, optional): after each reveal, say whether that matches what you see in real data. That’s the moment students hear industry reality, not just the textbook answer.
- Score each pitch out of 10, out loud:
- fit to the client: 0–4;
- originality of the twist: 0–3;
- would it work in AI-era search: 0–3.
- Judge vs Machine: the simulation scores each idea from 0 to 5. If you think it’s too generous or too harsh for this idea, say so. You can move it by one point and tell the class why. Students love it when the expert disagrees with the machine.
- Wildcard (if the host includes it): bring one wildcard question with a number answer from your own work (a trend, a statistic, a before-and-after). If you like, show a chart or tool for 60 seconds. In the full version’s plot twist, pick gold, silver and bronze for the best one-sentence saves.
- At the end: one piece of career advice for the class.
Good to know
- Everything shows on the host’s shared screen; you just talk. If you’re online, the host will read the team names for you.
- Please don’t share confidential client information. Anonymised or public examples are perfect.
- Your name and organisation appear on the winners’ certificates only if you’re happy with that. The host will ask.
Working with an industry partner
Use their real (or realistic) brief
Choose Your own client on the set-up screen and enter a client name, what they do, who searches for them, the goal, and up to two things that matter most. The simulation uses those two to judge fit. The partner can be the client themselves, as Pi Datametrics is in the built-in brief: a search intelligence company asking students how it could become the answer when marketers ask an AI assistant about its category.
Agree a few things first
- Whether the judge’s name and organisation can appear on screen and on certificates.
- Whether the “In collaboration with” line can name their organisation (it is added automatically when you use the Pi Datametrics brief).
- Whether they’re happy for you to share photos of the session, and what each certificate should say.
- The wildcard question and the brief, if they want to provide them.
- Nothing confidential goes into the brief.
Answer key
Round 1: Myth or Fact
| Statement | Answer | Why |
|---|---|---|
| AI Overviews need special AI markup or an AI text file such as llms.txt. | Myth | No additional requirements; no new machine-readable files, AI text files or special schema (Google, 2025). |
| More Google Ads spend lifts organic rankings. | Myth | Google never accepts payment to be included or ranked higher in search results (Google, n.d.-e). |
| Google picks one of several near-duplicate pages as the main version. | Fact | Canonicalisation (Google, n.d.-b). It links to keyword cannibalisation, where your own pages compete. |
| Google penalises a page simply because AI helped write it. | Myth | Quality matters, not the method; scaled content abuse is the problem (Google, 2023; n.d.-d). |
| Correct structured data guarantees a rich result. | Myth | It makes a page eligible; display isn’t guaranteed (Google, n.d.-f). |
| The meta keywords tag helps Google rankings. | Myth | Not used in web ranking (Google, 2009). |
| Clicks from AI Overviews and AI Mode are counted in Search Console. | Fact | Reported in the Performance report, “Web” search type (Google, 2025). |
Sprint uses the first three; Full uses five. “Swap statement” brings in one you haven’t used.
Round 2: the play cards and the simulation
Each card has four ratings from 0 to 3: classic search reach, reach in AI answers, speed to impact and risk. It also has tags that can match what the client needs. The machine’s score is:
classic + AI + ½ speed + 1½ × (needs matched, max 2) − 1½ × risk, scaled to 0–5
| Card | Classic | AI | Speed | Risk | Fits |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 🎓 Ask the expert | 3 | 3 | 1 | 0 | Trust, How-to, Comparison |
| 📊 Original data drop | 2 | 3 | 1 | 0 | B2B, Trust, New brand |
| ⚖️ Honest comparison | 3 | 2 | 2 | 1 | Comparison, Tiny budget |
| 📍 Local legend | 2 | 1 | 3 | 0 | Local, Tiny budget |
| 🎬 Show, don’t tell | 2 | 2 | 2 | 0 | How-to, Visual |
| 💬 Join the conversation | 1 | 2 | 2 | 1 | New brand, How-to |
| 🛠️ Fix the foundations | 2 | 2 | 3 | 0 | Tiny budget, Comparison, Trust |
| 📰 Make the news | 3 | 2 | 1 | 1 | New brand, Visual, B2B |
| 🏭 AI content factory (trap) | 0 | 0 | 3 | 3 | none: scaled content abuse (Google, n.d.-d) |
| 🔗 Link bundle (trap) | 0 | 0 | 3 | 3 | none: link spam (Google, n.d.-d) |
The ratings are the author’s teaching judgements, informed by Google’s documentation on helpful content, AI features, local ranking and spam (see Sources). They’re deliberately simple and open to challenge: that’s what “Judge vs Machine” is for.
The clients
- Pi Datametrics (real client): an SEO and AI search intelligence company. The teaching brief was written in collaboration with Pi Datametrics and is not the company’s actual plans. Goal: be the name marketers find, and that AI assistants recommend, when they ask how to track their brand’s visibility in AI search. What matters: B2B, Comparison.
- Your own client: enter a partner’s real brief or invent one. “Fill in an example” loads a fictional outdoor shop (Bothy & Bramble) to show the format.
Round 3: plot twists (Full)
- The answer moved: an AI answer tops the client’s main question and clicks fall. Look for: being the cited source, reasons to click, measuring it.
- The copycat: a richer rival copies the idea. Look for: things that can’t be copied, such as experience, data and community.
- Pages at war: three pages chase one search. Look for: merging, redirects or making the pages genuinely different.
- Half the budget: look for prioritising, with the cheap foundations first.
- Bad news travels: look for an honest response page, responding to reviews, and not hiding.
Debrief questions
- Which card would you pick for your own placement, project or dream employer, and why?
- Where did the judge disagree with the machine? Who was right, and what was the model missing?
- Why are the trap cards tempting, and what would you say to a client who asks for them?
- What still makes someone click when an AI answer appears at the top?
- What one thing will you keep doing in search marketing after this module?
Design choices and limits
- Low effort, high stakes. Students choose rather than research, so everyone can take part, including those less confident in English or new to the subject. The twist is where creativity shows.
- The simulation is a teaching model, not a forecast. Real results depend on the market, the competition, the site and the execution. The game says this on screen, and the judge can overrule it.
- Fictional clients. All built-in brands are invented. Real partners appear only if the host enters them, with permission.
- Privacy. Names and scores stay in the host’s browser (localStorage). Clearing the browser or pressing “New showdown” removes them.
- Accessibility. Keyboard operable, screen-reader labels and announcements, sound effects with an off switch, no flashing, and reduced motion respected. The certificates print in high contrast.
- Search moves fast. Statements and sources were checked on 17 November 2026. If Google changes its guidance, trust the newer source, and tell me so I can update the game.
Sources
- Google (2009) ‘Google does not use the keywords meta tag in web ranking’, Google Search Central Blog, 21 September. Available at: https://developers.google.com/search/blog/2009/09/google-does-not-use-keywords-meta-tag (opens in a new tab) (Accessed: 17 November 2026).
- Google (2023) ‘Google Search’s guidance about AI-generated content’, Google Search Central Blog, 8 February. Available at: https://developers.google.com/search/blog/2023/02/google-search-and-ai-content (opens in a new tab) (Accessed: 17 November 2026).
- Google (2024) ‘What web creators should know about our March 2024 core update and new spam policies’, Google Search Central Blog, March. Available at: https://developers.google.com/search/blog/2024/03/core-update-spam-policies (opens in a new tab) (Accessed: 17 November 2026).
- Google (2025) AI features and your website. Google Search Central, last updated 10 December 2025. Available at: https://developers.google.com/search/docs/appearance/ai-features (opens in a new tab) (Accessed: 17 November 2026).
- Google (n.d.-a) Creating helpful, reliable, people-first content. Google Search Central, last updated 5 October 2026. Available at: https://developers.google.com/search/docs/fundamentals/creating-helpful-content (opens in a new tab) (Accessed: 17 November 2026).
- Google (n.d.-b) What is canonicalization. Google Search Central. Available at: https://developers.google.com/search/docs/crawling-indexing/canonicalization (opens in a new tab) (Accessed: 17 November 2026).
- Google (n.d.-c) How to improve your local ranking on Google. Google Business Profile Help. Available at: https://support.google.com/business/answer/7091 (opens in a new tab) (Accessed: 17 November 2026).
- Google (n.d.-d) Spam policies for Google web search. Google Search Central, last updated 28 August 2026. Available at: https://developers.google.com/search/docs/essentials/spam-policies (opens in a new tab) (Accessed: 17 November 2026).
- Google (n.d.-e) Google Search consumer information. Google Search Help. Available at: https://support.google.com/websearch/answer/7585859 (opens in a new tab) (Accessed: 17 November 2026).
- Google (n.d.-f) Missing features in Google Search results. Search Console Help. Available at: https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/9079920 (opens in a new tab) (Accessed: 17 November 2026).
Google, Google Ads, Google Business Profile, Search Console and AI Overviews are trademarks of Google LLC, named for information only. No endorsement is implied.