Teacher's guide · Experiment 014

Source Check

A free, self-paced academic integrity game for students in any subject, from first-year essays to doctoral theses. Three rounds: judge six paraphrases of one source, find the fabricated references in an AI-assisted reference list, and sort eight uses of AI into green, amber or red. This guide covers the answers and a 15–30 minute induction plan.

15 to 30 minutes3 rounds, 60 pointsAny subject, any levelNo logins⏱ What affects timing
The idea

What students learn

1. Paraphrase or plagiarism?

Six drafts of one source show the difference between a real paraphrase, a correct quotation, patchwriting, copied words without quotation marks, and an uncredited idea. A highlighter shows the wording each draft shares with the source.

2. Ideas need credit too

One draft shares 0% of its wording with the source and is still plagiarism. Similarity checkers would miss it; students should not.

3. Check every reference

A reference list built with an AI chatbot mixes real papers, garbled details and invented articles. Students get three simulated library lookups, so they must decide where checking matters most.

4. AI: fine, check, or not acceptable

Eight common uses of AI, from asking for an explanation to uploading interview transcripts, sorted green, amber or red for a typical UK university.

Three ways to use it

Pick a format

Induction

A 15–30 minute activity in the first weeks of any programme, before the first assessment. This is the plan below.

Before a deadline

Post the link a fortnight before the first essay is due, and ask students to bring the AI scenario they disagreed with.

Postgraduate research

For doctoral training, Round 2 opens a conversation about reference management and checking sources, and Round 3 about data and AI tools.

Academic skills teams

Library and study skills teams can use it in drop-ins or embed the link in a referencing guide.

Read first

Five golden rules

  1. Answers lock when clicked.The explanation appears straight away. That is where the learning is.
  2. Three lookups only.In Round 2 students can check three of the six references. All six must be marked before submitting.
  3. Round 3 is about local rules.Answers reflect a typical UK university in October 2026. Rules differ between institutions and assessments, so follow it with your own policy (see “Your rules” below).
  4. The source is invented.Moreno (2021) and its passage are fictional, so nobody can look up the answer. The six references in Round 2 are a mix of real and fabricated items.
  5. Nothing leaves the device.There are no accounts, and no answers are sent anywhere.
How it is built

The three rounds

RoundTaskItemsPoints
1Judge each draft: acceptable, missing citation, too close to the original, or needs quotation marks6 drafts18 (3 each)
2Mark each reference genuine or suspicious, with three library lookups6 references18 (3 each)
3Sort each use of AI: usually fine, check the rules and declare it, or not acceptable8 scenarios24 (3 each)

Bands: Integrity Pro (51+), Careful Scholar (39+), Getting There (27+), At Risk. Badges: Source checked for finishing, Integrity pro for 51 or more.

Answer key

Every answer

Collapsed so students looking over your shoulder don’t see them. Open before the debrief.

Round 1: six drafts of Moreno (2021, p. 44)
DraftAnswerShared wordingWhy
AAcceptable0%A real paraphrase with new structure and vocabulary, credited.
BMissing citation96%Almost every word copied, no citation.
CToo close to the original76%Cited, but only a few words swapped: patchwriting.
DAcceptable68%Exact words, in quotation marks, with author, year and page.
EMissing citation0%Own words, but Moreno’s idea and finding, uncredited.
FNeeds quotation marks60%Credited, but the second half copies exact words without quotes.
Round 2: the reference list
ReferenceAnswerWhy
Braun and Clarke (2006), Qualitative Research in PsychologyGenuineOne of the most cited methods papers in the social sciences.
Kahneman and Tversky (2011), Psychological ReviewFabricatedTversky died in 1996; the real 2011 work is Kahneman’s book Thinking, fast and slow.
Watson and Crick (1953), NatureGenuineThe double helix paper.
Vaswani (2017), NatureNot genuine as citedA real paper with eight authors, published at NeurIPS, not Nature; page numbers invented.
Braun and Clarke (2014), “Thematic analysis in the age of generative AI”FabricatedReal authors and journal, but public generative AI arrived in late 2022.
Hardin (1968), ScienceGenuine“The tragedy of the commons”.
Round 3: AI use
ScenarioAnswerWhy
Asking AI to explain a statistics concept from a lectureGreenAI as a tutor; check against your notes.
Submitting what AI writes from the assignment briefRedNot your own work, under every university’s rules.
Adding AI-suggested references without reading themRedAI invents references; citing unread sources misrepresents your research.
Brainstorming research questions with AI, then developing your ownAmberOften allowed; check and declare.
Uploading interview transcripts to a free public AI toolRedBreaks participants’ consent and data protection.
Running a finished draft through AI for grammar and spellingAmberProofreading-level help is often allowed but sometimes restricted.
Turning lecture notes into practice quiz questionsGreenStudying, not submitting.
Writing in your first language and translating with AIAmberRules vary widely; ask first.

Draft E is the best debrief starter: a similarity checker would score it 0%, and it is still plagiarism. Draft D shows the opposite: 68% shared wording, and perfectly acceptable.

5 to 8 minutes

Before the session

  • Share lab.yingwu.co.uk/source-check/ as a link or QR code.
  • Have your own university’s academic integrity and AI guidance open, ready for the Round 3 discussion.
  • Play it once yourself: 12 to 20 minutes when you know the answers.
  • Open the answer key above, ready for the debrief.
Timing

How long will it take?

Every time in this guide is a range. The low end is a tight run; the top end is what most classes take once teams discuss, decide and react to the results.

In class: 15 to 30 minutesSolo: 12 to 20 minutes

What moves you up or down the range

  • When you call time. Students play at their own pace. Moving to the debrief once most have finished keeps you near the low end; waiting for everyone moves you to the top.
  • Reading every explanation. Students who read each explanation, as they should, take longer than those who rush to the next item.
  • Phones joining or loading. Sharing the link or QR code, patchy Wi-Fi and the three library lookups in Round 2.
  • Getting started. Explaining the three rounds and why integrity matters takes a few minutes, more with first-year students.
  • Interaction in between. Questions about your own university's rules, students comparing answers, or a tech hiccup.
  • The debrief. Draft E alone, or a full discussion of the AI scenarios with your own guidance on screen.
  • Your group. Familiarity with the topic, reading in a second language, and the room layout.

Short on time? Call time when most students have finished and debrief Draft E and one AI scenario. Want the richest discussion? Plan for the top of the range.

In class

Step by step

15 to 30 minutes, with students on their own phones or laptops.

  1. 0

    Set it up

    2 to 4 min
    Say
    “Three rounds on the habits that keep your work honest. Read every explanation, even when you are right.”
    Source Check start screen with the three rounds.
    The start screen: three rounds, 60 points.
  2. 1

    Play

    12 to 18 min
    Students
    1. Round 1: judge six drafts of the same source.
    2. Round 2: mark six references, using three library lookups.
    3. Round 3: sort eight uses of AI.
    Watch for
    • Students marking Draft E acceptable because the wording is their own.
    • Students using all three lookups on the first three references.
    Draft C with copied phrases highlighted and 76% shared wording.
    Round 1: the highlighter shows wording shared with the source.
    The reference list with three library lookups showing found, different details and no record.
    Round 2: three lookups, six calls to make.
    An AI-use scenario with green, amber and red options and the explanation.
    Round 3: green, amber or red.
  3. 2

    Debrief

    6 to 9 min
    Ask
    1. “Draft C cited its source but was still marked down. Is patchwriting as serious as copying without credit?”
    2. “Why do AI tools produce references that look right but do not exist?”
    3. “Here is our university’s AI guidance. Where does it put each amber scenario?”
    4. “Where is the line between help with your writing and someone else writing it?”
    Takeaway
    Credit words and ideas, find and read every source, and check the rules before using AI.
    Results screen with the score out of 60, the band, per-round bars and five habits to keep.
    The results: band, per-round bars and five habits to keep.
Your rules

Adapting Round 3 to your institution

  • Round 3 reflects a typical UK university in October 2026. If your policy differs, say so in the debrief: the disagreement is a teaching moment.
  • Many universities now use assessment-level categories (for example “AI not permitted”, “AI assistive use”, “AI integral”). Ask students which category each amber scenario would need.
  • The transcript scenario is red everywhere: it is a data protection and consent problem, not only an AI policy question.
Fixes

If something goes wrong

ProblemWhat to do
A student reloaded the pageThe game starts again from the beginning. Each round is short, so replaying is quick, and the second run is usually better.
"Copy result" does not copySome browsers block the clipboard. The text appears on screen instead: select it and copy by hand.
No devicesPut the game on the projector and play it as a whole class: read each item aloud, take a vote by show of hands, then click the room’s answer.
No Wi-FiOnce the page has loaded it runs without a connection. Otherwise, use the answer key on this page as a paper activity.
A student argues an amber answer should be greenGood. Check your own policy together. Rules genuinely differ, which is why the answer is amber.
Keep on your phone

Cheat card

  1. Share the link or QR code
  2. “Read every explanation.”
  3. 12 to 20 minutes of play
  4. Draft E: 0% shared wording, still plagiarism
  5. Show your own AI guidance for Round 3
  6. “Credit words and ideas; read every source.”
Sources

Behind the game

  • Howard, R.M. (1995) ‘Plagiarisms, authorships, and the academic death penalty’, College English, 57(7), pp. 788-806.
  • Quality Assurance Agency for Higher Education (2020) Academic Integrity Charter. qaa.ac.uk
  • Russell Group (2023) Principles on the use of generative AI tools in education. London: Russell Group.
  • Real references used in Round 2: Braun and Clarke (2006); Watson and Crick (1953); Vaswani et al. (2017); Hardin (1968). Kahneman (2011) Thinking, fast and slow is the real book behind the fabricated entry.

Moreno (2021) and its passage are invented for the game, and the library records are simulated.