Teacher's guide · Experiment 022

Too Many Plates

A free game on saying no, kindly and clearly. Learners pick two priorities, then face a week of requests from a manager, colleagues, friends, family and a sales email. For each one they can ask what is involved, choose one of five answers, pick (or write) their words, and hold the line when the asker pushes back. The debrief names their "no style" and gives them a pocket card. This guide is for lecturers, personal tutors, careers and wellbeing staff, coaches and trainers.

8 to 15 or 15 to 25 minutes6 or 10 requestsStudents, professionals, leadersPhones or laptopsNo logins, nothing saved⏱ What affects timing
The idea

What learners practise

1. Deciding before answering

Each request shows what it "looks like" and whether it fits the learner's two priorities. "Ask what is involved first" reveals the real cost. Several requests are bigger than they look, and some start next month.

2. More than yes or no

Five answers: yes, yes if (a condition), not now (a later date), no but (a smaller offer) and no. Learners discover the middle options protect both their week and the relationship.

3. Words that are warm and firm

Every answer except yes comes in three wordings: people-pleasing, blunt, and warm and firm. Learners can also type or speak their own words and get instant feedback on warmth, clarity, offers, apologies and vagueness.

4. Holding the line

"Oh go on, it's only an hour!" When the asker pushes back, learners choose between caving, over-explaining and a kind broken record. Pushback is where most people give in.

It suits professional skills and employability modules, wellbeing and resilience sessions, personal tutoring, new manager and leadership programmes, doctoral and early-career researcher development, and volunteer coordinator training. A key message: not every no is a good no. Small, generous yeses and requests that feed your priorities can earn a yes.

The meters

What the side panel tracks

Your week

A shelf of hours: 24, 20 or 16 free hours, depending on the level. Each commitment fills it. Hours beyond capacity show in pink and pull the priorities meter down by 2 points per hour over.

Future you

Hours already promised for next month. "Not now" moves a request there, and requests that start next month add to it when accepted. The debrief reflects on how next month always looks emptier.

Priorities, relationships, boundaries

Three meters from 0 to 100, starting at 40, 60 and 50. Saying yes to aligned requests feeds priorities; warm wording feeds relationships; holding the line and conditional answers build boundaries.

Your two priorities

Chosen at the start from five: your big project, career growth, health and rest, family and friends, and learning. They decide which requests "fit your priorities", and so which answers count as a good call.

The meters are a teaching device, not a measure of the learner. The people, requests and organisations are fictional.

Four ways to use it

Pick a format

Learner on their own

Share the link and the learner guide before a tutorial or coaching session. Ask learners to bring their copied pocket no's and one request they are currently unsure about.

Coaching or tutoring

Play together. Before each answer, ask: "What would you actually say on a Tuesday afternoon?" Then compare with the warm and firm option.

Pairs: asker and answerer

One learner reads the request and the pushback line aloud, the other answers in their own words before choosing in the game. This is the 60–75 minute workshop plan below.

One screen, whole room

Project the game and vote on each answer. At every pushback, ask two volunteers to say the kind broken record out loud. Laughter helps.

Read first

Five golden rules

  1. Nothing is saved.Priorities, answers and words stay in the open page and vanish when it closes. Learners can press "Copy my pocket no's" on the debrief. In "Say it in my own words", speaking uses the browser's own speech service (Google, Microsoft or Apple); typing works everywhere.
  2. Not every no is a good no.The game rewards yes to small favours and to requests that feed the learner's priorities. Say this early, or learners will assume the aim is to refuse everything.
  3. The own-words check reads wording, not intent.It looks for warmth, a clear answer, an offer, apologies, vague phrases and length. It cannot judge tone of voice or context.
  4. Some requests are not really optional.Power, caring duties, precarious contracts and cultural expectations all shape what people can refuse. Frame the game as practice for the many requests that are optional (see the note below).
  5. Nobody has to share their own situation.Discuss the fictional requests and patterns. Never ask learners to describe a real request they found hard, and let anyone pass.
Wellbeing and inclusion

Saying no is easier for some people than others. A request from a line manager, a caring responsibility, a fixed-term or zero-hours contract, visa conditions, or family and cultural expectations can make a request feel, or be, non-negotiable. The game deliberately mixes work and personal requests and offers middle options (yes if, not now, no but) because a flat no is not always available. Present it as practice for the many requests that are optional, keep discussion on the fictional characters ("What could you say to Priya?"), and avoid implying that people who say yes a lot are doing something wrong. If workload or wellbeing concerns come up, signpost your institution's support services rather than coaching individuals in the room.

How it is built

The 19 requests

A quick week draws 6, a full week 10. The game picks two (quick) or three (full) requests that fit the learner's priorities, one tiny favour or sales email, one that starts next month, and fills the rest at random. Guilt-trip mode always ends on the Friday 4:55pm email. "Looks" is the cost shown; "real" is revealed by asking first.

FromRequestLooks / realFitsPushback
Priya, your managerGive the induction talk on Thursday. "It's just an hour."1 h / 4 hSlides and a run-through.Career growth"Honestly, it's only an hour!"
Sam, colleagueReview a 40-page report by tomorrow morning.3 h / 3 hNone"You're the only one who really understands this stuff!"
Jo, friendHelp move flat on Saturday. "Pizza on me!"4 h / 5 hThe whole Saturday, and a sofa.Family and friends"But you're so good at this, and it'll be fun!"
Mike, neighbourBecome secretary of the residents' committee.2 h / 2 h now + 6 h next monthEvery week for a year.None"Nobody else will do it if you don't."
Aisha, junior colleague15 minutes of career advice.15 min / 15 minA tiny favour.Career growth, family and friendsNone
Dr Grant, directorJoin the strategy working group: two meetings this month.2 h / 3 hCareer growth, your big projectNone
Mei, your sisterHost the family dinner on Sunday.3 h / 4 hEight people.Family and friends"Mum will be so disappointed…"
Tom, colleagueCover a Tuesday session. "I'll owe you one."2 h / 2 hNone"Go on, you'd be saving my life."
Chris, software salesA 30-minute demo call.30 min / 30 minA cold sales ask.None"It'll only take a few minutes, I promise!"
Priya, Friday 4:55pmRedo the board slides tonight. "Urgent."Guilt-trip mode only.3 h / 3 hNone"I really need this. It's for the board."
Lou, parents' groupBake 50 cupcakes for Saturday's fair.3 h / 3 hNone"Everyone else is baking!"
Ravi, peerCo-write a paper. "A great opportunity."3 h / 3 h now + 8 h next monthTwo to three months of writing.Career growth, learning"Opportunities like this don't come round often!"
Kat, teamOrganise the team night out.2 h / 2 hNone"Nobody else ever does it!"
Dr Grant, directorTake on the new data course next term.2 h / 2 h now + 6 h next monthLearning, career growth"You're the obvious person for it."
Jo, friendTrain for a 10k: two early runs a week.2 h / 2 hHealth and rest, family and friendsNone
Ana, colleagueJoin the Wednesday lunchtime walk: 30 minutes, phones away.30 min / 30 minA small, generous yes.Health and rest, family and friendsNone
Mei, your sisterCome to Thursday evening yoga, a six-week beginners' class.1.5 h / 1.5 hHealth and rest, family and friends"Go on, you keep saying you need to do something for you!"
Priya, your managerKeep an eye on client emails over the weekend while she is away. "Just check in now and then."A rest request: protecting the weekend is the good call. Yes, if (an out-of-office), not now (Monday morning) and no, but (a Monday 8am check) are good calls; a flat no has a cost; yes is a rethink. If health and rest is a priority, yes costs 10 extra priority points and protecting it earns 4. Always included when learners choose health and rest.1 h / 4 hNone (protects health and rest)"It's just glancing at your phone, really."
Nadia, colleaguePair up on your big project: two short stand-ups a week.1 h / 1 hYour big projectNone

Health and rest is fed by three requests (the walk, yoga and the 10k), and protected by a fourth: the weekend email request, which is always included when learners choose health and rest. It is a useful discussion point: for people who overwork, a priority can be served by saying no as much as by saying yes.

Difficulty

Three levels

The first choice in setup. The debrief offers "A tougher week" to move up a level.

LevelFree hoursPushbackAlso
Easy24NoneGentle askers: good for a first go or a nervous group.
Standard20About half of the eligible requests push backThe default.
Guilt-trip mode16Every eligible request pushes backThe week ends with the Friday 4:55pm "urgent" email from the manager.

A request can push back only if it has a pushback line (12 of the 16 do) and the learner did not say yes.

Scoring

How the game keeps score

Everything is worked out on the learner's device from their choices.

FeatureHow it works
Good call, with a cost, rethinkEach final answer is judged against the request and the learner's priorities. Fits a priority, small: yes or yes if is a good call; not now or no but has a cost; no is a rethink. Fits a priority, big (3 or more hours, including next month): yes if or not now is a good call; yes or no but has a cost; no is a rethink. Does not fit, big: no, no but or not now is a good call; yes if has a cost; yes is a rethink. Does not fit, small: yes, yes if or no but is a good call; no or not now has a cost.
Special casesThe sales email: no is the good call. Aisha's 15 minutes (a tiny favour): yes or yes if is the good call; no is a rethink. The Friday 4:55pm email: yes if, not now or no but (fix the key slides on Monday) is the good call; no has a cost; yes is a rethink.
HoursYes adds the real cost this week (and any next-month cost to future you). Yes if trims the cost by the value of the condition and halves next month's. Not now moves everything to next month. No but costs 15 minutes or 1 hour for the offer. No costs nothing.
MetersYes: relationships +6; priorities +12 if it fits, −8 if not; boundaries −6 if it does not fit. Yes if: relationships +4, priorities +10 if it fits (−3 if not), boundaries +4. Not now: relationships +1, priorities +3 or +2, boundaries +2. No but: relationships +3, priorities −2 if it fits (+4 if not), boundaries +4. No: relationships −2 (−6 for a tiny favour), priorities −6 if it fits (+5 if not), boundaries +5 (−1 for a tiny favour).
WordingWarm and firm: relationships +4, boundaries +2. Blunt: relationships −6, boundaries +1. People-pleasing: relationships +1, boundaries −4. A people-pleasing “Yes, if…” (“I’ll find the time somehow”) drops the condition, so it is scored as a plain yes.
PushbackCave: the answer becomes a yes, boundaries −8, relationships +1. Over-explain: boundaries −2, relationships −1. Kind broken record: boundaries +6, relationships +1.
Own wordsLearners can type or speak their reply. The check looks for: a warm opener (thanks, appreciate); a clear answer (a no, a "can't", an explicit "if", or a date rather than "later"); a concrete offer ("I can", "what I can do", "instead"); more than one "sorry"; vague words ("maybe", "we'll see", "let me think"); and length (over 45 words is flagged as over-explaining). The reply is then classed as warm and firm, blunt or people-pleasing and scored like the chosen wordings.
Coach's noteAfter each request, a short note explains the call, adds a line about the wording style, and points out when the request was bigger than it looked and the learner did not ask first.
No styleThe debrief names one of five styles: the people-pleaser (several costly yeses or caves), the steamroller (many blunt replies), the hedger (many people-pleasing, vague replies), the kind gatekeeper (60% or more good calls) or finding your no (a mix). It also shows good calls, free hours left, pushbacks held, future-you hours and how often the learner asked first.
Every answer

The answers, wordings and pocket no's

Use these as a listening sheet when learners answer out loud. The words in braces are filled in from each request.

Open the five answers and their wordings

Yes

  • Do it all. No wording step: the hours go straight into the week.

Best for small favours and requests that feed your priorities and fit your week.

Yes, if…

  • People-pleasing: "Yes, of course! I'll find the time somehow, don't worry."
  • Blunt: "Only if {trade}."
  • Warm and firm: "Yes, happy to, if {trade}. Does that work for you?"

A condition protects the week without closing the door.

Not now

  • People-pleasing: "Maybe later? I'll see how things go and let you know…"
  • Blunt: "Not now."
  • Warm and firm: "Not this time, {name}. I could do it {date}, if that helps. Shall I put it in?"

A date, not a maybe. Remember it lands on future you.

No, but…

  • People-pleasing: "Oh, sorry, sorry, I really can't… but maybe I could try to {offer}, if that's OK?"
  • Blunt: "Can't do it. I can {offer}, that's all."
  • Warm and firm: "I can't take on {task}, {name}, but I can {offer}. Would that help?"

A smaller, specific offer keeps the relationship.

No

  • People-pleasing: "Oh gosh, I'd love to, it's just, things are a bit mad, sorry, maybe, I don't know…"
  • Blunt: "No, I can't."
  • Warm and firm: "Thanks for thinking of me, {name}. I'm going to say no to {task}, so I can give {my first priority} the time it needs."

Thanks, a clear no, and the yes behind it.

Under pushback

  • Cave: "Oh… OK then, fine. I'll do it."
  • Over-explain: "It's just that I have so much on, there's this, and that, and also…"
  • Kind broken record: "I hear you, {name}, and I'd like to help. It's still a no this week. My offer stands."

Same no, warmly, with no new reasons.

Open the pocket no's and the six habits

Pocket no's

  • The warm no: "Thanks for thinking of me. I'm going to say no to this one."
  • The no, but: "I can't take on the whole thing, but I can… Would that help?"
  • The yes, if: "Yes, happy to, if … comes off my plate."
  • The not now: "Not this week. I could do the 14th. Shall I put it in?"
  • The policy: "I don't take on new committees during term time."
  • The broken record: "I hear you, and I'd like to help. It's still a no. My offer stands."
  • The pause: "Let me check my week and come back to you by 3."
  • The ask first: "What would it involve, and by when?"

Six habits

  • Ask first.
  • Check it against your two priorities.
  • Give a date, not a maybe.
  • Make it a policy.
  • Be a kind broken record.
  • Remember future you.

These appear at the end of the debrief, with a sentence each.

10 to 15 minutes

Before the session

  • Share lab.yingwu.co.uk/too-many-plates/ as a link or QR code, and the learner guide at lab.yingwu.co.uk/too-many-plates/learn/.
  • Play a quick week yourself on Standard, once answering as you really would and once aiming for good calls.
  • Choose a level. Standard suits most groups; Easy suits a first go or a nervous group; Guilt-trip mode makes a lively second round.
  • Plan the space for pairs answering out loud. The own-words microphone needs Chrome, Edge or Safari; typing works everywhere.
  • Read the wellbeing and inclusion note above, and have your institution's support links to hand.
Timing

How long will it take?

Every time in this guide is a range. The low end is a focused run; the top end is what most learners take once they stop to think, read the feedback and try again.

Quick week: 8 to 15 minutesFull week: 15 to 25 minutesIn a workshop: 60 to 75 minutes

What moves you up or down the range

  • How long you spend thinking before each answer. Asking first, checking the request against your priorities and the meters, and picking the words.
  • Pushback. Easy has none; Standard has some and Guilt-trip mode has lots, and each pushback is another decision.
  • Whether you read every feedback note. Reading each note and the model wording, or moving straight on to the next request.
  • Replays and retries. Playing another week to try a different answer or level.
  • Reading or listening in a second language. Requests and wording styles take longer to read when English is not your first language.
  • In a workshop. Pairs reading requests aloud and answering in their own words, and how strictly the facilitator keeps time.

Each step below has its own range. Few sessions reach the top of every step, so the step ranges add up to more than the session range: if one step runs long, shorten a later one to stay within your slot.

Short on time? Play a quick week on Standard and read the feedback for the hardest request only. Want the richest practice? Plan for the top of the range.

Class workshop

A 60–75 minute "kind no" workshop

For 6 to 40 learners, each with a phone or laptop. They play alone first, then practise out loud in pairs.

  1. 0

    Set the tone

    5 to 10 min
    Say
    "Saying no feels awkward for almost everyone. Today is practice for the many requests that are optional. Not every no is a good no, and nobody sees your answers."
    Learners
    Open the game, choose Standard and Quick week, and pick two priorities.
  2. 1

    Solo quick week

    12 to 18 min
    Learners
    1. For each request, decide whether to ask first, then choose an answer and a wording.
    2. Try "Say it in my own words" at least twice.
    3. Read the coach's note, then the debrief, and copy the pocket no's.
    Watch for
    • Learners never pressing "Ask first". Ask what changed when they did.
    • Learners saying no to everything. Point them to the small favours and the priority-fit requests.
  3. 2

    Pairs: asker and answerer

    25 to 38 min
    Set up
    Pairs, one device, Guilt-trip mode, Quick week. Swap roles every request.
    Asker
    Reads the request aloud in character, then, if the game shows pushback, reads the pushback line with feeling.
    Answerer
    1. Answers out loud in their own words before touching the screen.
    2. Then picks the closest option in the game, or types their words into "Say it in my own words".
    3. Under pushback, tries the kind broken record out loud: same no, no new reasons.
    Watch for
    • Over-explaining under pushback. Ask: "Did your new reason help, or give them something to argue with?"
    • Blunt no's. Ask the asker how it felt to hear it.
  4. 3

    Debrief

    13 to 20 min
    Ask
    1. "What was your no style? Did it surprise you?"
    2. "Which request was bigger than it looked?"
    3. "When was yes the right answer?"
    4. "How did 'not now, on the 14th' feel compared with 'maybe later'?"
    5. "What does 'I don't take on…' do that 'I can't' does not?"
    6. "Which pocket no will you borrow first?"
    Takeaway
    Ask first, check against your priorities, give a date not a maybe, and under pushback, be a kind broken record. A good no protects what matters; a good yes feeds it.
  5. 4

    Close

    5 to 10 min
    Learners
    Copy their pocket no's and write one personal policy ("I don't… during…"). Finishing a week also earns the No, but nicely badge on their device, if they want to share it.
    Say
    "Next time someone asks for something, your first words are: 'What would it involve, and by when?'"
Fixes

If something goes wrong

ProblemWhat to do
"Start Monday" is greyed outLearners must pick exactly two priorities. Choosing a third swaps out the first one picked.
No pushback appearedEasy has none, and on Standard about half of eligible requests push back. Four requests never push back, and a yes is never pushed. Use Guilt-trip mode to guarantee pushback.
A learner closed or reloaded the pageThe week is gone: nothing is stored. The browser warns before leaving mid-week. A quick week takes 8 to 15 minutes.
The microphone does not workSpeaking needs Chrome, Edge or Safari and microphone permission. Typing the words works everywhere.
"My own words were marked people-pleasing"The check reads wording: more than one sorry, a vague "maybe" or no clear answer tips it there. Ask the learner to try again with a thanks, a clear answer and one offer.
A learner says "I can't say no to my manager"That may be true. Point to yes if and not now, and to the Friday email, where the good call is an offer for Monday morning, not a no.
"Copy my pocket no's" does not copySome browsers block the clipboard. Take a screenshot of the pocket card instead.
Keep on your phone

Cheat card

  1. Share lab.yingwu.co.uk/too-many-plates/
  2. "Practice for the optional ones. Not every no is a good no."
  3. Solo: Standard, quick week, two priorities, ask first
  4. Pairs: Guilt-trip mode, say it out loud before choosing
  5. Under pushback: same no, no new reasons
  6. Debrief: no style, biggest surprise, one personal policy
Built for professional skills and wellbeing teaching

Use it in employability and professional skills modules, wellbeing and resilience sessions, personal tutoring, researcher development and new manager programmes. Pair it with The Meeting Room, which has a "say no kindly" moment in a live meeting, and The Long Game on keeping fewer, better promises. Open Too Many Plates →

Sources

Behind the game

  • Flynn, F.J. and Lake, V.K.B. (2008) 'If you need help, just ask: Underestimating compliance with direct requests for help', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 95(1), pp. 128-143. doi:10.1037/0022-3514.95.1.128
  • Patrick, V.M. and Hagtvedt, H. (2012) '"I don't" versus "I can't": When empowered refusal motivates goal-directed behavior', Journal of Consumer Research, 39(2), pp. 371-381. doi:10.1086/663212
  • Simons, T. (2002) 'Behavioral integrity: The perceived alignment between managers' words and deeds as a research focus', Organization Science, 13(1), pp. 18-35. doi:10.1287/orsc.13.1.18.543
  • Zauberman, G. and Lynch, J.G. (2005) 'Resource slack and propensity to discount delayed investments of time versus money', Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 134(1), pp. 23-37. doi:10.1037/0096-3445.134.1.23

How the sources inform the game: people tend to underestimate how readily others agree to direct requests, partly because saying no feels awkward, which is why the game rehearses the awkward moment, including pushback; people tend to expect more spare time in the future than they have now, which makes future time commitments feel cheaper, hence "future you"; framing a refusal as "I don't" (a personal rule) rather than "I can't" helped people stick to their goals, hence "make it a policy"; and keeping fewer promises, and keeping them, connects to behavioural integrity, the perceived match between words and deeds. The "yes, if", "not now" and "no, but" moves are widely taught practical techniques rather than findings from these studies. The requests, people and meters are fictional teaching devices, and the meter values are illustrative, not research findings.