What it is, and why
Every research project involving people needs ethical approval, from an undergraduate survey to a PhD. Here you sit on the committee instead. Each of six applications comes from a different discipline. You flag issues through eight lenses, then decide: approve, approve with amendments, or reject for major resubmission. The committee secretary’s letter tells you what the experienced members spotted and what change they would ask for. Reviewing other people’s applications is the fastest way to write a better one yourself.
Made for learning on your own
Everything here works on your own, at your own pace. These are the parts built so more people can learn from it:
⏳ No clock
There is no time limit. Read each screen as slowly as you like, re-read the explanations, and come back to it later.
HelpsSlower readers, dyslexic learners, people working in a second language, and anyone who thinks best without pressure.
🔍 The same eight lenses every time
Every application is checked against the same eight lenses, so you build one checklist you can reuse for your own form.
HelpsLearners who like structure, including many autistic and ADHD learners, and anyone new to research.
⚖️ Fair scoring
Judgement calls cost nothing either way, and the letter explains why, so you are never punished for a reasonable view.
HelpsAnxious learners and anyone who worries about “getting it wrong”.
💡 Learn from every answer
After each choice you see a decision letter with the change a committee would ask for, not just a right or wrong mark. The learning is in the reasons.
HelpsLearners who missed the class, revise on their own, or want to check their thinking without asking in front of others.
📱 Phone, tablet or laptop
It works in any modern browser and reflows to a narrow phone screen, so you can play on the bus or in a lunch break.
HelpsCommuters, carers, part-time and online learners who study in short gaps.
🔒 No account, no audience
No sign-up and no class watching. Your answers are not sent anywhere, and badges stay on your device.
HelpsAnyone who would rather make mistakes in private first, including anxious learners and people new to the topic.
Four steps
- Read the application
Who are the participants, what will happen to them, and what data is collected?
- Flag the issues
+2 for each real issue, −1 for a flag on a non-issue. Don’t tick everything.
- Make the decision
Approve, approve with amendments, or reject for major resubmission: +4 if you match the committee.
- Read the letter
There is no back button: the letter is where the learning is. Score 85% for Chair of the board.
Six habits of a good ethics reviewer
✍️ Consent people can understand
Plain-language information, a real choice, and a clear way to withdraw.
🛡️ Look for vulnerability and power
Children, people who may lack capacity, and anyone the researcher has power over need extra care.
🔐 Follow the data
What is collected, where it is stored, who sees it and when it is deleted.
🎭 Debrief after deception
If participants are misled for good reason, tell them the truth afterwards.
🧑🔬 Remember the researcher
Fieldwork and sensitive topics can put the researcher at risk too.
🟢 Keep it proportionate
Low-risk studies should simply be approved. Good committees enable research.
Your pocket card
If this happens, try this
| What happens | What to try |
|---|---|
| You lost points for flagging too much | Ask “is this a real risk here?” Ticking everything blocks good research. |
| You approved one that needed changes | Read the letter for the specific change requested, and add it to your checklist. |
| A study needed a different committee | Some research, such as with adults who may lack capacity, has its own route. Check with your ethics office. |
| A lens was arguable | Judgement calls cost nothing. Read why the committee saw it that way. |
| You’re about to write your own form | Use the eight lenses as headings, then bring your least certain point to supervision. |
Take your own research idea and write one line for each of the eight lenses. Mark the one you are least sure about, then replay one application that covers it.
Want more? Rehearse another panel in The Viva Room, and check your referencing and AI use in Source Check. Supervisors: the supervisor’s guide has a 45-minute workshop plan and every decision letter.