Learner guide · Experiment 045

Lens Switch

A plan can look fine through one lens and fail through another. Judge one campaign through four ethical lenses, back each judgement with evidence, and decide what to change before it launches.

8 to 12 minutes4 lenses, 24 pointsNo time limitPhone friendly
In 30 seconds

What it is, and why

A bottle brand has a back-to-school campaign ready to go. You judge it through four ethical lenses: consequences, rights, justice and virtue. For each lens you rate the plan, pick the strongest evidence from the board, then choose what to change before launch. The point is that a plan can do real good and still fail on consent, fairness or honesty. Switching lenses shows you more of the picture.

Inclusive by design

Made for learning on your own

Everything here works on your own, at your own pace. These are the parts built so more people can learn from it:

📋 A model to copy

The end screen builds a model table (criterion, rating, evidence, so what) that you can copy into your notes as a pattern for your own report.

HelpsLearners who find academic writing hard to start, and anyone who learns best from a worked example.

📌 Keeps your place

If the page reloads or you get interrupted, your progress is kept in that browser tab, so you can pick up where you left off.

HelpsCarers, parents, commuters, and anyone whose study time gets interrupted.

⏳ Your pace

There is no countdown. Open as many explanations as you like; the time on the card is a guide, not a limit.

HelpsSlower readers, dyslexic learners, people working in a second language, and anyone who thinks best without pressure.

💡 Learn from every answer

After each choice you see why each judgement, piece of evidence and change scores, not just a right or wrong mark. The learning is in the reasons.

HelpsLearners who missed the class, revise on their own, or want to check their thinking without asking in front of others.

📱 Phone, tablet or laptop

It works in any modern browser and reflows to a narrow phone screen, so you can play on the bus or in a lunch break.

HelpsCommuters, carers, part-time and online learners who study in short gaps.

🔒 No account, no audience

No sign-up and no class watching. Your answers are not sent anywhere, and badges stay on your device.

HelpsAnyone who would rather make mistakes in private first, including anxious learners and people new to the topic.

How to play

Four steps

  1. Read the brief

    Meet the campaign. Add a nickname if you like; it stays on your device.

  2. Rate each lens

    Strong, moderate, weak or not at all. Close ratings still earn a point.

  3. Prove it

    Pick the evidence that best supports your judgement.

  4. Decide the change

    Choose what to fix before launch. Score 21 or more for the Clear sighted badge.

Pro moves

Six habits for ethical judgement

⚖️ Weigh, don’t demand zero

The consequences lens weighs benefits against harms with evidence. Some harm doesn’t automatically sink a plan.

✋ Credit isn’t consent

Reposting customers’ photos in adverts needs permission, especially when children are in them.

🤲 Ask who carries the cost

The justice lens asks whether benefits and burdens fall fairly, including on people with less power.

🪞 Check the character

The virtue lens asks what the plan says about the brand: honest, or just good at sounding it?

🌿 Prove green claims

An unchecked “carbon neutral” claim fails on honesty and on the Green Claims Code.

🔧 End with a change

Ethical analysis should end in something to do differently, not just a verdict.

Screenshot me

Your pocket card

ConsequencesWho benefits, who is harmed, how much?
RightsConsent, privacy, honesty to each person.
JusticeIs the burden shared fairly?
VirtueWhat would an honest brand do?
EvidenceSpecific, checkable, not a slogan.
ChangeOne fix before launch.
Slip-ups and quick fixes

If this happens, try this

What happensWhat to try
The plan looks fine to youSwitch lens. Ask about consent, then fairness, then honesty.
Your rating was one step offYou still get a point. Check which evidence tipped it.
All the changes sound sensiblePick the one that fixes the weakest lens you found.
“Copy the table” does nothingSome browsers block copying. Select the table on screen and copy it by hand.
You closed the tabProgress is kept only while the tab is open. Start again; it takes about ten minutes.
Try this tonight: one ad, four lenses

Pick an advert you saw today. Give it one line for each lens. Which lens does it fail? Then replay and see whether you rate the campaign differently.

Want more? Keep practising the same method: analyse a marketing mix in Four Cs Check, and test green claims in Greenwash Detective. Running this with a group? The teacher’s guide has a seminar plan and the case in full.